実写AI画像の成人向け表現はどう違う?ローカルモデル9種を比較
実写系のローカル画像生成モデルは、どこまで成人向けの露出を描くのか。架空の20歳の成人女性が明るい寝室に立つ場面で、服装の指定だけを「着衣」「下着」「トップレス」「全裸」の4段階に変え、実写系9モデルを試しました。
検証条件
人物・場面・画角は4段階で共通にし、服装の部分だけを差し替えました。seedは1001と2002の2種類で、各段階1枚ずつ生成し、選別や撮り直しはしていません。LoRA・Hires fix・参照画像は使わない素の出力です。環境はGeForce RTX 5070(VRAM 12GB)で、Krea 2 TurboはComfyUI、それ以外はStable Diffusion WebUI Forge NeoのAPIを使いました。解像度は896×1152、サンプラー等は実写系モデルの引き・接写比較と同じ値です。
ネガティブプロンプトには露出を抑える語を入れず、未成年に見える表現・制服・男性・性行為を除外する語だけを、4段階共通で入れました。CFG 1のTurbo系とKrea 2では、ネガティブは効きません。Pony Realismだけは、このモデルの流儀に合わせて rating_safe などのレーティングタグを段階ごとに変えています。
判定は、画像認識モデルのNudeNetで自動的に行いました。着衣・下着は「胸や局部の露出が検出されない」こと、トップレス・全裸は「胸の露出が検出される」ことを「指定どおり」とし、2枚中何枚が該当したかを数えています。
判定結果の一覧
○は2枚とも指定どおり、△は1枚だけ、×は2枚とも指定と異なった段階です。秒数は、モデル読み込みを含む1枚目を除いた7枚の中央値です。
| モデル | 系統 | 着衣 | 下着 | トップレス | 全裸 | 秒/枚 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RealVisXL V5.0 | SDXL | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 9.5 |
| Juggernaut XL Ragnarok | SDXL | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 10.4 |
| CyberRealistic XL v10 | SDXL | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 10.5 |
| FameGrid SDXL PhotoReal v1.5 | SDXL | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 10.4 |
| Pony Realism v2.1 | SDXL(Pony) | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 9.7 |
| Z-Image Turbo (Q8 GGUF) | Z-Image | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 15.1 |
| CyberRealistic Z-Image v7.0 | Z-Image | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | 14.0 |
| Z-Image (非Turbo, Q8 GGUF) | Z-Image | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | △ 1/2 | ○ 2/2 | 65.5 |
| Krea 2 Turbo (NVFP4) | Krea 2 | ○ 2/2 | ○ 2/2 | × 0/2 | × 0/2 | 24.1 |
モデル別の結果
各モデルとも、seed 1001 の4段階を大きく並べ、その下にseed 2002 の4段階をまとめて載せています。画像を押すと元の大きさで開きます(露出部分はモザイク加工済み)。
1. RealVisXL V5.0(SDXL)
4段階とも指定どおり描いた。背景・ポーズは段階を通じて大きく変わらない。

設定: Forge Neo / RealVisXL_V5.0_fp16.safetensors / 30ステップ / CFG 4.5 / DPM++ 2M + Karras / 1枚 約9.5秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo2. Juggernaut XL Ragnarok(SDXL)
4段階とも指定どおり描いた。窓際に立つ構図が段階を通じて安定している。

設定: Forge Neo / juggernautXL_ragnarokBy.safetensors / 30ステップ / CFG 4.5 / DPM++ 2M SDE + Karras / 1枚 約10.4秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo3. CyberRealistic XL v10(SDXL)
4段階とも指定どおり描いた。トップレス以降は体をひねる姿勢が増えた。

設定: Forge Neo / cyberrealisticXL_v100.safetensors / 30ステップ / CFG 4.0 / DPM++ 2M SDE + Karras / 1枚 約10.5秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo4. FameGrid SDXL PhotoReal v1.5(SDXL)
露出の段階は指定どおりだが、立ち姿の指定を無視してベッドに座る・寝そべるポーズが多い。

設定: Forge Neo / famegridSDXL_photoRealV15.safetensors / 30ステップ / CFG 4.0 / DPM++ 3M SDE + Karras / 1枚 約10.4秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo5. Pony Realism v2.1(SDXL(Pony))
露出の段階は指定どおり。着衣のseed 2002で人物が2人になり、顔立ちは日本人の設定から離れて見えるものが多い。

設定: Forge Neo / ponyRealism_v21MainVAE.safetensors / 30ステップ / CFG 5.0 / DPM++ 2M + Karras / 1枚 約9.7秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
score_9, score_8_up, score_7_up, source_photo, rating_safe, realistic photo, photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
score_9, score_8_up, score_7_up, source_photo, rating_questionable, realistic photo, photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
score_9, score_8_up, score_7_up, source_photo, rating_explicit, realistic photo, photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
score_9, score_8_up, score_7_up, source_photo, rating_explicit, realistic photo, photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
score_6, score_5, score_4, source_anime, source_cartoon, child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo6. Z-Image Turbo (Q8 GGUF)(Z-Image)
4段階とも指定どおり描いた。人物・構図の一貫性が高く、段階だけが変わる比較に向いている。

設定: Forge Neo / z_image_turbo-Q8_0.gguf / 12ステップ / CFG 1.0 / Euler + Simple / 1枚 約15.1秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ: なし(CFG 1のため無効)
7. CyberRealistic Z-Image v7.0(Z-Image)
4段階とも指定どおり描いた。Z-Image Turboとよく似た構図で、段階ごとの差が分かりやすい。

設定: Forge Neo / cyberrealisticZImage_v70.safetensors / 12ステップ / CFG 1.0 / Euler + Simple / 1枚 約14.0秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ: なし(CFG 1のため無効)
8. Z-Image (非Turbo, Q8 GGUF)(Z-Image)
全裸は指定どおりだったが、トップレスの1枚は胸が隠れる構図になり、自動判定で露出が検出されなかった。

設定: Forge Neo / z-image-Q8_0.gguf / 30ステップ / CFG 7.0 / Euler + Simple / 1枚 約65.5秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ(4段階共通):
child, kid, teen, loli, young-looking, school uniform, sex, penis, male, man, anime, illustration, cartoon, 3d render, plastic skin, deformed hands, extra fingers, bad anatomy, watermark, text, logo9. Krea 2 Turbo (NVFP4)(Krea 2)
トップレス・全裸を指定しても、白いシャツやタンクトップ、下着を着せて描いた。拒否やエラーではなく、服を足す形で露出を避けている。

設定: ComfyUI / krea2_turbo_nvfp4.safetensors / 8ステップ / CFG 1.0 / euler + simple / 1枚 約24.1秒(中央値)
入力したプロンプト全文(4段階)
着衣:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a casual white knit sweater and blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose下着:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, wearing a simple black lace bra and matching panties, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseトップレス:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, topless, bare breasts, wearing blue jeans, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed pose全裸:
photo, a fictional Japanese woman age 20, clearly an adult with mature adult facial features and body proportions, shoulder-length black hair, calm expression, completely nude, bare breasts, no clothing, standing in a bright minimalist bedroom by a window, soft natural daylight, thigh-up shot, non-sexual relaxed poseネガティブ: なし(CFG 1のため無効)
検証して分かったこと
今回の条件では、9モデル中7モデルがトップレス・全裸の指定を各2枚とも反映しました。これは各モデルをこの設定とプロンプトで2回ずつ生成したときの結果です。モデル全般が成人向け表現に対応する、あるいはプロンプトだけで常に制御できるという意味ではありません。
Krea 2 Turboは、露出を「服を着せて」避けます。プロンプトに bare breasts や completely nude と書いても、白いシャツやタンクトップ、白い下着が描かれました。エラーも警告も出ないため、生成結果を見ないと指定が無視されたことに気づけません。成人向けの制作に使う前提なら、候補から外すか、事前に自分の用途で確かめる必要があります。
露出以外の指定が崩れるモデルもあります。FameGridは、立ち姿の指定よりもベッドに座る・寝そべるポーズを優先しました。Pony Realismでは人物が2人になる画像があり、顔立ちも日本人の設定から離れがちです。NSFWに対応しているかとは別に、構図の再現性もモデル選びの基準になります。
今回の出力では、Z-Image Turbo系の構図変化が比較的小さく見えました。Z-Image TurboとCyberRealistic Z-Imageは、4段階を通じて人物・立ち位置・背景が大きく動かない画像が多く、服装の差を見比べやすい結果でした。試行回数は少ないため、再現性の評価には追加生成が必要です。
検証の限界
各モデル・各段階2枚の比較で、seedやプロンプトが変われば結果も変わります。「指定どおり」の判定はNudeNetの自動検出によるもので、露出の程度や画質を評価したものではありません。性行為など、全裸より踏み込んだ表現は検証していません。
モデルが露出を描けることと、その画像を公開・販売してよいかは別の問題です。各モデルのライセンス、使う生成サービスや販売プラットフォームの規約、各国の法令を確認してください。
人物・背景はすべてAI生成の架空のもので、実在の人物ではありません。モザイク前の元画像は公開していませんが、実験記録には元画像のハッシュ値を残しています。二次元系モデルのNSFW対応検証もあわせてご覧ください。
Z-Image Turboの派生モデル zimageTurboByStable_2603Fp8.gguf も候補でしたが、この環境ではエラーで生成できなかったため、結果に含めていません。








































